4 Reasons why re-dedication does not work.
I learned a long time ago that making New Year resolutions is a waste of time. A New Year resolution is like rededicating your life to Christ over and over again, it just doesn’t work. Why do we do this anyway? Why do we rededicate our lives to Christ? I for one cannot count the number of times that I have either walked down an aisle with a new inner promise to “do it right this time for you Lord.” I can’t remember the number of times I have prayed that prayer (of salvation) just to make sure I get it right this time. I often wonder to myself how many converts walking down the church aisles every Sunday are actually new converts or old ones just trying again by re-commitment. Whatever the case, I keep coming to the same conclusion, the novelty of rededication wears off almost as quickly as our will to keep our New Year resolutions.
I learned yesterday that one of my cousins who just finished his basic training in the navy got re-baptized again this weekend. This is his third baptism in the last 5 years. And while I applaud him for doing so, because I know that he is sincerely searching for an authentic relationship with God, I know that the premise of his actions is erroneous. He was saved and baptized once before, he need not keep doing it again. He wrote me a letter saying that he is really dedicated to God now and to doing it right this time. I have been there, I know how he feels, I don’t want to burst his bubble by telling him that if your plan is to “do it right” then get ready for an annual habit of re-dedications and empty promises.
Here are 4 reasons why re-dedication does not work:
1. Rededication is focused on what “I can do for God”. If we are saved and secured by God’s grace through Jesus, like the Scriptures teach, then why do we need to keep rededicated ourselves to God? Rededication is nothing more than a human attempt to validate something that we did not purchase in the first place. It is like someone trying to pay off a billion dollar debt in 5 years when they only make $50,000 annually. It is literally impossible. But somehow, because we live in a meritocratic society, we think that our efforts actually secure God’s provision. I believe that there is much to learn from Zechariah 4:6 where God says, “…'Not by might nor by power, but by my Spirit,' says the LORD Almighty.”
2. Rededication is nothing more than a commitment to Law while ignoring the message of Grace. While we say that we believe that the fundamental reality of our relationship with God is made so by His grace, most of us have serious doubts about this truth, so we constantly try to live up to the precepts of Biblical Law. We think that the fruit of the spirit means that we will be able to be more obedient to Biblical Law if we will simply re-commit or rededicate ourselves to God. I have news for you, it does not work. Even a casual reading through the writings of the Apostle Paul, especially Romans and Galatians, shows the futility of trying to grow spiritually by obeying Biblical Law. This is why he had such harsh comments to the church at Galatia when he wrote:
You foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you? Before your very eyes Jesus Christ was clearly portrayed as crucified. I would like to learn just one thing from you: Did you receive the Spirit by observing the law, or by believing what you heard? Are you so foolish? After beginning with the Spirit, are you now trying to attain your goal by human effort? Have you suffered so much for nothing—if it really was for nothing? Does God give you his Spirit and work miracles among you because you observe the law, or because you believe what you heard? Galatians 3:1-5
Most of us really think that God blesses us primarily because we obey Biblical Law, when the reality is that none of us is doing (or can ever do) as well as we would need to in order to earn God’s blessings. This is why we need His grace. The cross is the ultimate symbol of grace.
3. Rededication fuels human pride. There is no sin that is as insidious as human pride. Pride say “I can do it by myself, if I just try hard enough”, even when all the evidence points otherwise. Pride places all the entire burden for growth and development on self, and is the root of self-righteousness. Humility on the other hand is an admission of powerlessness apart from God; this is why the first step in any addiction recovery program starts by saying something like, “I can’t overcome this, my problem is too big for me, and I am overwhelmed”. This is the beginning of brokenness, and for many of us, yours truly included, brokenness is hard for us to get to because we stubbornly feel that we can “self-help” ourselves to a more productive life. If I pray more, tithe more consistently, go to church more, have enough accountability partners, and dedicate myself to ministry more, read my Bible for one more hour instead of two..etc You get the idea. This kind of stuff may give you a superficial appearance of “righteousness”, but it does nothing to free you on the inside. And while there is nothing wrong with doing these things, we are being legalistic when we do them as a means to an end instead of as a by-product of our relationship with God and our desire to commune with Him and others. And legalism is nothing more then a neatly packaged form of bondage that has become so common in the church.
4. Rededication ignores the simple message of the cross: How many times did Christ have to go to the cross? Only once. He only had to do it once because his sacrifice for humanity was good for all time, remember God is eternal and is not bound by time constraints. Time is necessary for us, not for God, because God sees all of time like a perpetual now. So if Jesus only had to die only once and our faith in Him connects us to the reality of our status as God’s children, why do we keep rededicating ourselves to Him? Could it be that we doubt our eternal security? Or are we trying to get God to love us more or bless us more, so we think that by our feeble acts of rededication, God will be so impressed that he will finally succumb to our endless cries? Doing this shows that many of us have a false understanding or the differences between the New and the Old Covenants. The Old Covenant was one of constant rededication, constant killing of bulls and goats for cleansing of sin, constant trying to get it right with empty promises of “real commitment”. The writer of Hebrews put it this way:
The law is only a shadow of the good things that are coming—not the realities themselves. For this reason it can never, by the same sacrifices repeated endlessly year after year, make perfect those who draw near to worship. If it could, would they not have stopped being offered? For the worshipers would have been cleansed once for all, and would no longer have felt guilty for their sins. But those sacrifices are an annual reminder of sins, because it is impossible for the blood of bulls and goats to take away sins. Hebrews 10:1-4
Just as it is impossible for the annual sacrifice of the blood of bulls and goats to take away sins, it is impossible for acts of rededication to make you any better a child of God than you were before the re-commitment. Any Christian who is really sincere with themselves knows that rededication does nothing to improve your spirituality, all it does is give you a false sense of security by saying “well, I am on the right track now because I did something, I rededicated myself to God.” But you were on the right track when you placed your faith in Him the first time, and once you have done it once, you need not do it again because you are eternally secure. The New Covenant says that I am totally accepted, loved, complete and whole because of the sacrifice of Jesus at Calvary. It is not what I have done, but what He did for me.
I know how subtle this message of trying to stay committed by re-commitment is. Several years ago, I was a member of a growing charismatic church. I was asked to lead what was known as the ‘Harvest Ministry' to minister to new-believers-in-Christ as part of a new class. One of the lines in the handbook that I was given to teach said the following: "..One is responsible for keeping his own gift [of salvation]. Once one has given his life to Christ, God is not responsible for your staying saved and Satan is not responsible for your sins....one is responsible for keeping his gift by studying God's Word.” (italics added). The implication here was that you do not necessarily remain God's child once you are saved (in other words you are not eternally secure) since you need to do certain things - like studying His word and obey his commandments- to stay "saved". This is a popular concept that is not Biblical; it is actually contradictory to the doctrine of salvation by God's grace alone. Grace and Law do not mix. Our salvation is either all of God's Grace or it is not Grace at all. We are scared that people will gloat in sin like a pig in mud if we do not give religious stipulations, but to do so is to add a yoke of bondage to believers that is really not necessary. Only God’s spirit of love can motivate true obedience anyway, and this obedience is to His spirit of grace, not to the Law. This is what Romans 6:14 means when Paul says, “….you are not under law, but under grace.” I eventually made the choice to leave that church that preached this message of maintaining salvation by obedience to the Law, because the pastor and I could not agree on this issue, so I amiably left in search for a church that I felt was standing on the truth of our eternal security in Christ.
As one who knows first hand what it is like to struggle with a bad habit, I know how appealing acts like rededication (and self-imposed actions of willpower) really are. But guess what? These actions don't work or bring real freedom. I believe Paul knew this first hand when he wrote:
Such regulations indeed have an appearance of wisdom, with their self-imposed worship, their false humility and their harsh treatment of the body, but they lack any value in restraining sensual indulgence. Colossians 2:23
So the bottom line is whose power are you going to trust, yours or God’s? Trusting in self by rededication will only lead to further heartbreak, trusting in God’s power and strength does not mean that life will be all peaches and cream, but at least you will have the assurance that come hell or high water, whatever the outcome for better or for worse, you are secure in His hands. Only God has the power to liberate us from our demons, our past, and our own fallibility.
I learned a long time ago that making New Year resolutions is a waste of time. A New Year resolution is like rededicating your life to Christ over and over again, it just doesn’t work. Why do we do this anyway? Why do we rededicate our lives to Christ? I for one cannot count the number of times that I have either walked down an aisle with a new inner promise to “do it right this time for you Lord.” I can’t remember the number of times I have prayed that prayer (of salvation) just to make sure I get it right this time. I often wonder to myself how many converts walking down the church aisles every Sunday are actually new converts or old ones just trying again by re-commitment. Whatever the case, I keep coming to the same conclusion, the novelty of rededication wears off almost as quickly as our will to keep our New Year resolutions.
I learned yesterday that one of my cousins who just finished his basic training in the navy got re-baptized again this weekend. This is his third baptism in the last 5 years. And while I applaud him for doing so, because I know that he is sincerely searching for an authentic relationship with God, I know that the premise of his actions is erroneous. He was saved and baptized once before, he need not keep doing it again. He wrote me a letter saying that he is really dedicated to God now and to doing it right this time. I have been there, I know how he feels, I don’t want to burst his bubble by telling him that if your plan is to “do it right” then get ready for an annual habit of re-dedications and empty promises.
Here are 4 reasons why re-dedication does not work:
1. Rededication is focused on what “I can do for God”. If we are saved and secured by God’s grace through Jesus, like the Scriptures teach, then why do we need to keep rededicated ourselves to God? Rededication is nothing more than a human attempt to validate something that we did not purchase in the first place. It is like someone trying to pay off a billion dollar debt in 5 years when they only make $50,000 annually. It is literally impossible. But somehow, because we live in a meritocratic society, we think that our efforts actually secure God’s provision. I believe that there is much to learn from Zechariah 4:6 where God says, “…'Not by might nor by power, but by my Spirit,' says the LORD Almighty.”
2. Rededication is nothing more than a commitment to Law while ignoring the message of Grace. While we say that we believe that the fundamental reality of our relationship with God is made so by His grace, most of us have serious doubts about this truth, so we constantly try to live up to the precepts of Biblical Law. We think that the fruit of the spirit means that we will be able to be more obedient to Biblical Law if we will simply re-commit or rededicate ourselves to God. I have news for you, it does not work. Even a casual reading through the writings of the Apostle Paul, especially Romans and Galatians, shows the futility of trying to grow spiritually by obeying Biblical Law. This is why he had such harsh comments to the church at Galatia when he wrote:
You foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you? Before your very eyes Jesus Christ was clearly portrayed as crucified. I would like to learn just one thing from you: Did you receive the Spirit by observing the law, or by believing what you heard? Are you so foolish? After beginning with the Spirit, are you now trying to attain your goal by human effort? Have you suffered so much for nothing—if it really was for nothing? Does God give you his Spirit and work miracles among you because you observe the law, or because you believe what you heard? Galatians 3:1-5
Most of us really think that God blesses us primarily because we obey Biblical Law, when the reality is that none of us is doing (or can ever do) as well as we would need to in order to earn God’s blessings. This is why we need His grace. The cross is the ultimate symbol of grace.
3. Rededication fuels human pride. There is no sin that is as insidious as human pride. Pride say “I can do it by myself, if I just try hard enough”, even when all the evidence points otherwise. Pride places all the entire burden for growth and development on self, and is the root of self-righteousness. Humility on the other hand is an admission of powerlessness apart from God; this is why the first step in any addiction recovery program starts by saying something like, “I can’t overcome this, my problem is too big for me, and I am overwhelmed”. This is the beginning of brokenness, and for many of us, yours truly included, brokenness is hard for us to get to because we stubbornly feel that we can “self-help” ourselves to a more productive life. If I pray more, tithe more consistently, go to church more, have enough accountability partners, and dedicate myself to ministry more, read my Bible for one more hour instead of two..etc You get the idea. This kind of stuff may give you a superficial appearance of “righteousness”, but it does nothing to free you on the inside. And while there is nothing wrong with doing these things, we are being legalistic when we do them as a means to an end instead of as a by-product of our relationship with God and our desire to commune with Him and others. And legalism is nothing more then a neatly packaged form of bondage that has become so common in the church.
4. Rededication ignores the simple message of the cross: How many times did Christ have to go to the cross? Only once. He only had to do it once because his sacrifice for humanity was good for all time, remember God is eternal and is not bound by time constraints. Time is necessary for us, not for God, because God sees all of time like a perpetual now. So if Jesus only had to die only once and our faith in Him connects us to the reality of our status as God’s children, why do we keep rededicating ourselves to Him? Could it be that we doubt our eternal security? Or are we trying to get God to love us more or bless us more, so we think that by our feeble acts of rededication, God will be so impressed that he will finally succumb to our endless cries? Doing this shows that many of us have a false understanding or the differences between the New and the Old Covenants. The Old Covenant was one of constant rededication, constant killing of bulls and goats for cleansing of sin, constant trying to get it right with empty promises of “real commitment”. The writer of Hebrews put it this way:
The law is only a shadow of the good things that are coming—not the realities themselves. For this reason it can never, by the same sacrifices repeated endlessly year after year, make perfect those who draw near to worship. If it could, would they not have stopped being offered? For the worshipers would have been cleansed once for all, and would no longer have felt guilty for their sins. But those sacrifices are an annual reminder of sins, because it is impossible for the blood of bulls and goats to take away sins. Hebrews 10:1-4
Just as it is impossible for the annual sacrifice of the blood of bulls and goats to take away sins, it is impossible for acts of rededication to make you any better a child of God than you were before the re-commitment. Any Christian who is really sincere with themselves knows that rededication does nothing to improve your spirituality, all it does is give you a false sense of security by saying “well, I am on the right track now because I did something, I rededicated myself to God.” But you were on the right track when you placed your faith in Him the first time, and once you have done it once, you need not do it again because you are eternally secure. The New Covenant says that I am totally accepted, loved, complete and whole because of the sacrifice of Jesus at Calvary. It is not what I have done, but what He did for me.
I know how subtle this message of trying to stay committed by re-commitment is. Several years ago, I was a member of a growing charismatic church. I was asked to lead what was known as the ‘Harvest Ministry' to minister to new-believers-in-Christ as part of a new class. One of the lines in the handbook that I was given to teach said the following: "..One is responsible for keeping his own gift [of salvation]. Once one has given his life to Christ, God is not responsible for your staying saved and Satan is not responsible for your sins....one is responsible for keeping his gift by studying God's Word.” (italics added). The implication here was that you do not necessarily remain God's child once you are saved (in other words you are not eternally secure) since you need to do certain things - like studying His word and obey his commandments- to stay "saved". This is a popular concept that is not Biblical; it is actually contradictory to the doctrine of salvation by God's grace alone. Grace and Law do not mix. Our salvation is either all of God's Grace or it is not Grace at all. We are scared that people will gloat in sin like a pig in mud if we do not give religious stipulations, but to do so is to add a yoke of bondage to believers that is really not necessary. Only God’s spirit of love can motivate true obedience anyway, and this obedience is to His spirit of grace, not to the Law. This is what Romans 6:14 means when Paul says, “….you are not under law, but under grace.” I eventually made the choice to leave that church that preached this message of maintaining salvation by obedience to the Law, because the pastor and I could not agree on this issue, so I amiably left in search for a church that I felt was standing on the truth of our eternal security in Christ.
As one who knows first hand what it is like to struggle with a bad habit, I know how appealing acts like rededication (and self-imposed actions of willpower) really are. But guess what? These actions don't work or bring real freedom. I believe Paul knew this first hand when he wrote:
Such regulations indeed have an appearance of wisdom, with their self-imposed worship, their false humility and their harsh treatment of the body, but they lack any value in restraining sensual indulgence. Colossians 2:23
So the bottom line is whose power are you going to trust, yours or God’s? Trusting in self by rededication will only lead to further heartbreak, trusting in God’s power and strength does not mean that life will be all peaches and cream, but at least you will have the assurance that come hell or high water, whatever the outcome for better or for worse, you are secure in His hands. Only God has the power to liberate us from our demons, our past, and our own fallibility.

